Pathways to Consensus
The world is facing unprecedented systemic challenges of both ecological and economic nature that are straining not only our resources but also the intellectual frameworks and finance/economics theories on which we have relied for several generations. We continue to be burdened by a lack of political resolve and a market system that, in pursuing short-term profits, has directed trillions of dollars of global capital into economic activities that are now posing a danger to not only markets and economies, but also to our society and our planet. These disconnects need urgent attention. To address them, we must do more than tinker on the margins of our existing disciplines. We need to break through and create new understandings about the true systems of interdependence, correlation, and causality that link and drive our world. What we need, in effect, is a thoughtful rewiring of the source code of capitalism. The recognition of this problem is widespread and it has sparked pioneering new thinking around the world. Innovation is both deepening and accelerating. The landscape is full of new, exciting, and complicated theories and practices. In many ways we are witnessing the emergence of whole new “ecosystems of thought,” within which innovators are:
- mapping and measuring the financial materiality of sustainability to firms and investors;
- chronicling the negative externalities of impact materiality, or how those same firms and investors affect our global biosphere and civilization;
- implementing promising new theories and practices of impact investing, which seeks joint financial and sustainability gains;
- working on how to mitigate harm and improve outcomes within major specific domains such as climate change, water use, biodiversity, inequality, and many others.
Yet, the creative force that hurls people into new corners of thought must be matched by efforts to find common ground. To make progress, a blend of creation and consensus, innovation and standardization, vision and practicality is required. This takes time and can only be accomplished through careful discussions among the innovators. Some of those discussions can take place in writing. Others need to happen through careful, curated conversations. To succeed, it is important to provide a platform for such discussions—a platform that brings together and fosters dialogue among the key players (from the private and public sectors, policymakers, and academia), that explores pathways to consensus and a shared vision, and that stimulates the co-creation of a more sustainable world. The Sustainable Investing Research Initiative (SIRI) provides such a platform.
SIRI Decisionmakers Roundtable Discussion on Pathways to Consensus
SIRI’s inaugural Decisionmakers Roundtable Discussion on Exploring Pathways to Consensus was held on June 6-7, 2024, at Columbia University. It brought together a carefully curated set of key leaders from around the world, including academics, industry experts, innovators, standard setters, philanthropies, and policymakers. The aim of this convening was to enhance dialogue amongst key players, identify challenges, build a shared vision, find common ground, and stimulate renewed commitments and collaborations. Besides fostering dialogue and actions, the convening also provided an opportunity to share insights of academic research and present new innovations and best practices.
The participants discussed the following key areas:
- Experiences and key insights from existing efforts: financial and impact materiality in disclosure as well as impact investing.
- Perspectives and approaches on emerging topics: system-level investing, fiduciary duty, and intergenerational equity.
- Next steps needed – Exploring pathways to a shared vision: building bridges between ecosystems of thought, engaging academic institutions, and creating avenues for future collaboration.
Following the success of the Inaugural SIRI Pathways to Consensus Decisionmakers Roundtable Discussion in Spring 2024, SIRI plans to hold future annual convenings bringing together a carefully curated set of leaders from the private and public sectors and academia. Following the convenings, a report summarizing the key insights and discussion points will be drafted and shared with participants as well as posted on this webpage.
Read the summaries from the concluded events below.
Past Events
- Inaugural SIRI Pathways to Consensus Roundtable Discussion | June 6-7, 2024 [Summary]
- 2nd SIRI Pathways to Consensus Roundtable Discussion: “Re-Writing the Source Code of Capitalism” | June 9-10, 2025 [Summary]
Columbia University Sustainable Finance Forum
Co-Chairs: Caroline Flammer and Bob Massie
The Sustainable Finance Forum is a monthly online event that offers a 'roving spotlight' that pulls together major academics, organizational leaders, and industry practitioners from the US, UK, and Europe to learn about and to discuss major topics in the field of sustainable finance.
Past sessions have focused on the evolution of sustainability reporting and its use in the financial assessment of firms, the evolution of shareholder primacy, new approaches to blended finance, the need for national legislation to reform pension legislative, and at threat by the current SEC to rescind the 84-year-old rule that gives shareholders the chance to file resolutions on the company’s proxy.
From the expert presentations and dialogue, students and other participants will gain a rare, early window into rapidly accelerating controversies and will hear the cutting-edge perspectives of some of the most important thought leaders in the field.
Held the first Wednesday of every month from 12:00 to 1:30 US Eastern time, the Forum is divided into two parts.
- In the first 45-minute segment, one or more senior experts present on key topics and then engage in a conversation with each other moderated by Robert K. Massie, Jr, Director of the SIRI Pathways to Consensus Program and Senior Research Scholar.
- In the second half, the floor is open to Forum participants, who are faculty, organizational leaders, and other experts. This year we have opened the forum to SIPA graduate students, who are considered Observers, who are invited to listen and to offer comments in the chat.
Fall 2026 Dates:
- Wed September 10th 12:00 - 1:30pm ET | Topic: Twin Catastrophes, One Blind Spot: Climate, AI, and the Law Governing America's Retirement System | Summary
- Wed October 7th 12:00 - 1:30pm ET | Topic: Who Gets a Say? Rule 14a-8 and the Future of Shareholder Voice |
- Wed November 4th 12:00 - 1:30pm ET | Topic: How will financial measurements, values, and rewards be transformed when new technology makes planetary damage more fully visible?
- Wed December 2nd 12:00 - 1:30pm ET | Topic: The Changing Role of the CFO
Spring 2027 Dates
- Wed January 6th, 12:00 - 1:30pm ET
- Wed February 2nd, 12:00 - 1:30pm ET
- Wed March 3rd, 12:00 - 1:30pm ET
- Wed April 7th, 12:00 - 1:30pm ET
- Wed May 5th, 12:00 - 1:30pm ET
- Wed June 2nd, 12:00 - 1:30pm ET
Past events
Spring 2025 Dates:
- Tue February 4th 12:00 - 1:30pm ET | Topic: The Evolution of Fiduciary Duty | Summary
- Tue March 4th 12:00 - 1:30pm ET | Topic: The Rollback of Corporate and Investor Transparency Rules in the US and Europe | Summary
- Tue April 1st 12:00 - 1:30pm ET | Topic: Sustainability Disclosure Standards for Financial Services | Summary
- Tue May 6th 12:00 - 1:30pm ET | Topic: Rewriting the Source Code of Capitalism:
The Integration of Fiduciary Duty, System-level Investment, and Sustainability Disclosure | Summary - Tue June 3rd, 12:00 - 1:30pm ET | Topic: The Omnibus Bill and the Future
of Sustainability Disclosure in the European Union | Summary
Fall 2025 Dates:
- Tue September 2nd 12:00 - 1:30pm ET | Topic: Advances in Impact Investing: Triggering Systems Change | Summary
- Tue October 7th 12:00 - 1:30pm ET | Topic: How to Catalyze More Private Capital Through Blended Financing Structures to Finance Innovative Solutions | Summary
- Tue November 4th 12:00 - 1:30pm ET | Topic: The Future of Multicapitalism and Integrated Reporting | Summary
- Tue December 2nd 12:00 - 1:30pm ET | Topic: Taking Externalities into Account: Assumptions, Limitations, Pathways, and Integrating Opportunities | Summary
Spring 2026 Dates:
- Wed February 4th 12:00 - 1:30pm ET | Topic: The Impact of AI+ on
- Fiduciary Duty, System-level Investing, and Measurement, Reporting, and Validation (MRV) | Summary
- Wed March 4th 12:00 - 1:30pm ET | Topic: AI, Impact, and Trust: Redefining Measurement and Verification in Sustainable Finance | Summary
- Wed April 1st 12:00 - 1:30pm ET | Topic: How can reporting frameworks best support the low-carbon transition? | Summary
- Wed May 6th 12:00 - 1:30pm ET | Buried Treasure: How Experts Uncover Financial Value and Hidden Risks in Sustainability Data | Summary
Wed June 3rd 12:00 - 1:30pm ET | When Visibility Changes Responsibility: Governance, Duty, and the Future of Sustainable Finance | Summary